Punish China For The Right Reasons.

Paul Krugman has been the instigator of what is now a vast chorus to view the underevaluation of the Chinese currency as a serious problem. I do agree, sort of, but I extend the critique to the US dollar: it, too is undervalued.

So, according to Paul, China has got to be punished, because it exports its savings, and we are so incompetent, we do not know what to do with them, because we are not expansionary enough... As it is, this reminds me a bit of punishing people, because they saved too much, and were too industrious, thus owning too much, in part thanks of an alleged conspiracy of them... Hmmm... Was not that exactly the Nazis' main drift against a particular minority?

Being also as bad as they come, I also want to punish the Chinese, but only to encourage them to become better planetary citizens. I do think that the technological and economic, not to say social stagnation of the West is the West's problem, not China, and China ought not to be punished for it. Instead the West ought to be punished for not striving to stay on top of the existing hierarchy, and on top of the planetary problems we have.

Not to preserve the existing hierarchy will lead to instability, hence war. Same with not solving the drastic ecological problems (acidification, water, climate change, population growth).

If China manipulates its currency, it has to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. First. Also the duties ought to correspond to the minimum of the proven depreciation; if the renminbi is undervalued by 10% minimum, then impose 10% minimum duties, etc.

China working hard and saving is a good thing. We ought to emulate it. What we ought to not emulate, and encourage China to get out of, is its carbon solution. Reigning in our plutocrats, in bed with the Chinese dictatorship, is our problem, not China's. Just as the plutocrats out-maneuvered the Nazis, in the end, they will out-maneuver China at the first occasion. They out-maneuvered us on health care, and with the on-going existence of their vampiric financial scheme. We do not want them to out-maneuver us again, using China as a trampoline.

http://patriceayme.wordpress.com/